Carmax vs cargurus reddit 95 to list your car on the CarGurus platform. Get Started: Make a Debt-Free Future Your Reality More: 17 Hidden Auto Costs Your Dealer Sep 1, 2021 · We compare price offers for our example car, a staffer's three-year-old Subaru, from Carvana, Vroom, CarMax, KBB, and the local dealership, among others. CarMax offered me $3500 for the Forester and honored it even when it cut off on them as they were driving it into the garage for inspection. . Good luck with the sale! Listed on Cargurus, facebook marketplace, and craigslist. com for a $3,500 down payment. Sep 3, 2023 · Car Listings – CarGurus has millions of nationwide listings from dealers and private sellers Vs. You can return a car for up to 30 days simply for not liking it, and they'll also ship within their dealer network for you to get the exact car you want. Used cars for sale on carmax. Used consumer reports for a search and one of the cars I liked was "not found" when I clicked on it. Try Vroom as well, they have been competitive with Carvana. If you are willing to do some due diligence you can fish around on cargurus. 5K and 21K. Bought a car with clean report from carmax. Last time I actually sold/traded a car at a dealer was 20 years ago (trading an old Infiniti for a new one). It took about 20 minutes and they drove away with my car. ), and pricing with the CarGurus Used Car search engine. the process is even faster than Carmax's Find your perfect car with help from our experts. If your offer is less than the amount you owe, you'll need to either pay off your loan before we can pay you, or pay us the difference before we can pay your lender. I have a 2020 Kia Forte GT 6sp with 19k miles and 0 issues or defects (I rate it good, not excellent, it's not a show car) CarMax - $17,500 Driveway - $16,250 Carvana - $17,600 Looking for any experience with selling a used car to CarGurus. Omaha, NE “My consultant was very patient and helpful throughout the whole financing process. The online places sometimes want to make an offer, take your car and ship it to another city. Some people has better offer from Carvana and others have better from Carmax, I am the latter case. Each used car sold by Carvana or CarMax comes with a limited warranty. See full list on agirlsguidetocars. Call up Greg at Cooper Auto Group, he is the used car buyer for all of their lots and is less than one mile away from CarMax Edmond. CarGurus offer is valid for 7 days or an additional 250 miles, while CarMax offer is only valid for 7 days. I used to love wheeling and dealing on used cars, but as I’ve gotten older, the less I like dealing with the general public. Carmax is fine but overpriced for what you are getting. Low price, easy and safe: Carmax (and maybe then "we give $500 more than Carmax" dealership) MUCH better price (Carmax offered me $7K for a car with $11K private party value and I got the $11K for a few hours effort), need to know what you are doing: CarGurus, Autotrader, Craigslist, FB Marketplace. ” Also, if you end up needing to return the vehicle or it needs immediate repairs, not only is the clock ticking on YOU once it arrives… you can’t get back any cash you shelled out for shipping on a return. I sold to Carmax last August and it was unbelievably painless (in and out in 45 mins). In 2021, CarMax generated $31. 2015 Nissan XTerra 2WD. Depends on the car. The dealers trade in offer can be less than carmax’s as long as you still win on the taxes. ” Robert F. Prices from $2,500 to $84,785; Includes CarFax and KBB ratings; Cars from dealerships; Payment calculator available "A+ rating from the BBB; True Car is an online marketplace that makes it easy to find your next used car, with potentially 12,000+ listings available within 50 miles of your location. Take your vehicle to CarMax to get the verified offer, which is good for 7 days. Your car is definitely worth close to 50 but it just depends on how much time your willing to put into the sale! Sep 17, 2023 · Online offers from carmax and carvana were 20. CarGurus is the best online car buying site for CarMax like every dealer on earth has to pay curtailments on floor plan financing when inventory ages, thus they start reducing prices before sending back through auction. I prequalified for a few vehicles on CarMax. Dealer Offer: $8,500. CarGurus uses auto check mostly and it’s really annoying because i hate auto check. Once you get used to the filters it's by far the best platform. Now that we’ve covered the basics, let’s compare some of the key differences between Carfax and Cargurus: Purpose Carmax is a ripoff and charges more than you’d pay for new cars with low mileage (I. A private buyer claims 39k. 4 days ago · Autotrader. Used Honda Civic vs. I then meet the buyer at their financial institution and take either cash or a cashier's check directly from their financial institution, in person. 5hr to CT or haggle with different dealers which is a pain. com Carmax has given me kbb trade in value for used cars too in the past, so it definitely happens. Craigslist is much more shadier than FB MP in my opinion. CarMax claims to have the nation’s largest inventory of used cars. May 27, 2022 · Limited warranty: 100 days or 4,189 miles 90 days or 4,000 miles 90 days or 6,000 miles Home delivery fee: $0 within local market $0 within 60 miles of select markets CarMax and Carvana have given me the most on their offer for both my cars. Initially was going to just give to carmax but I didn't feel like they were being honest in the quote they gave. Prices from $9,990 to $99,990; Cars all sold by Carvana, no dealerships or private sellers; Includes CarFax; Large inventory; Short Carvana is a unique online car-buying platform that offers a 100% digital experience, allowing you to browse and purchase used cars from the comfort of your own home. Select Make Unbiased car reviews and over a million opinions and photos from real people. Buy Used Cars Online with CarGurus. I've had good experiences with CarMax before, but when they didn't lower their initial trade-in offer I was happy I was wearing a mask because the grin on my face would have been too much. Honestly, I would go with CARMAX as an alternative. Mar 30, 2025 · True Car. Browse the best April 2025 deals on Chevrolet Corvette vehicles for sale. com has. He was able to beat the CarMax offer. If you live in a state where taxes are calculated post trade in, I suggest getting an offer letter from carmax, and taking that to the dealer. It really sucks as this does really affect car value. Both only sell vehicles that are reconditioned to look new and both offer additional warranties to ensure the vehicle is working properly. 5 days ago · CarMax. “CarMax showed and explained all financing options without pressuring us one way or another. Both buyers were looking for the exact car for months. I looked at the photos on Cars & Bids to pick great angles. Carmax is convenient, but they have a bit of a reputation for lowballing - though this is not always the case by any means. My husband and I just bought a BMW 330e and a Tesla model 3 from CarMax this week. I’m no motorhead by any stretch of the imagination, but I like knowing how things work and I like maintaining my own stuff rather than paying someone to do something I could learn and do in my own garage. A couple years ago I sold a different car to Carmax, it was $4000 vs $3000 (Carvana). They gave me a good price, and I also checked the value a year earlier and they gave me a good price then as well. Orlando, FL 2012 Honda Accord Coupe V6. Price Data – CarGurus shows real-time asking prices while TrueCar displays historical average paid prices. The future of sustainable transportation is here! This is the Reddit community for EV owners and enthusiasts. But charged $1/mile during that trial period. How legit is Cargurus vs Vroom? I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. I want: Mid size suv (think ford explorer to chevy traverse) 4 corner height adjustable air suspension Highly capable 4x4 system for offroad use that has atleast 4x4 high and low Panoramic sunroof Nice interior High towing capacity (planning on towing something like an R-pod travel If you're looking for a large car, turn your attention to a full-size sedan and find all the space and amenities you’ll need. The money was ACH deposited into my bank account the next morning. Yeah, I use AutoTempest and then click on their links to go through to AutoTrader and Cargurus. com, Carvana, Edmunds, CarMax and TrueCar are the best websites for buying and selling used cars; Edmunds leads the way for buying a used car online since it makes it easy for consumers to CarGurus is a reputable online car marketplace that's been helping people buy and sell cars since 2006. It depends on a lot in the market, but also, a car that is 100,000 miles vs 99,200 makes a huge difference, customers are less likely to buy a car with that big ol' 1 in the front of the mileage. You’ll have peace of mind with both CarMax and Carvana offering a 7-day money-back guarantee. Carvana offer was low. Some life changes this fall have enabled my family to go down to one car, so we opted to keep the larger vehicle and sell the smaller vehicle. Financing a used car through a dealership is easy—and you can even start the process online, right here on CarGurus. Doesn't matter to carmax as long as they get the full retail value. Sep 8, 2023 · So, in summary, Cargurus doesn’t provide vehicle histories, but gives you tons of up-to-date listing information to simplify your used car search. CARFAX. Said the car was not a desirable model and they would just take the car to auction. Use our car search or research makes and models with customer reviews, expert reviews, and more. So another car forum, people recommend carvana. So: I started exploring direct sale to Vroom, Carmax, and Carvana. Basically you can leave with the carmax financing and have 3 business days to find something better to replace it with. Get the search started with our list of the 10 best full-size sedans for 2021 shoppers, based on CarMax sales data from February 1, 2021, through July 31, 2021. Once the inspection is done, the reconditioning report (recon report) is sent over to the parts department, which, in this case, was an Auto Zone attached to the service department. Thus far, the platform has sold over 9 million cars and appraised another 33 million. com When it comes to Carvana, CarMax, and CarGurus, each platform has its unique advantages and drawbacks. So I didn't even bother shopping the local dealers. I'd come pick them up in the car they wanted to buy and they'd end up writing the check over to us for down payment lol. If you’ve accepted an 100% online offer from CarGurus and the offer is greater than the amount you owe on your car loan, we'll pay off your loan and send you the difference. I feel skeptical to buy from them as I'm surprised they don't thoroughly check your car when they pick it up I wonder what the process is once it gets to a Carvana hub and personally I have heard some horror stories in my family of buying from Carvana last year hopefully that changes anyways If you want to sell Carvana is offering the highest amount of money compared to CarMax and dealers so I On a whim, I opted for a KBB "Instant Cash" offer for my car this morning. Private sale should save you a couple of thousands. Ebay, Cargurus, Autotrader, and the likes mostly cater to dealers. For what it’s worth I’ve owned a normal amount of cars for somebody my age. Carmax wasn't very convenient to me. Actually I think CarMax has the hands down best search interface. CarMax: Warranties and Insurance. com is also good but doesn’t have a ton of listings on it. Sold Private: $14,999. Recently bought a new car, did not trade in my paid off oldie since I know I can get a higher offer through CarMax or private sell. Search used cars, research vehicle models, and compare cars, all online at carmax. So the chances of finding one that you want to buy are pretty good. Shift does not operate in my area. Dec 9, 2022 · Today, CarMax operates 235 stores across the nation that are managed by the 25,000+ associates it employs. CarMax treated me right. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. For CarGurus/Autotrader I wish distances were fully variable because from my Zip code 300 miles reaches Dallas but not houston and 500 miles gets me crap from Oklahoma 4 days ago · Carvana. Length of time on lot is great too (no price changes for me in Texas). Carmax is fine giving you a buyers order and waiting a day. This Auto Zone ONLY served CarMax (a win-win deal for both companies - CarMax leveraged Auto Zone's buying/procurement power, and AutoZone leveraged CarMax's volume). Sold the car to CarGurus on Tuesday afternoon, July 19, money was in my bank account this morning. While the traditional dealer model still accounts for the majority of car sales, online car retailers like Carvana and comparison sites like CarGurus are quickly gaining ground by promising a simpler, more transparentContinue Reading → But if you go that route make sure to set a budget before you go and don't budge on it. If you don’t, you can return it for a full refund. com reviews and ranks the best Used Car Sites available today. I don't know if posting on craigslist is worth it anymore. I got nothing but lowball offers from dealers who offered between $17K and $20K and private buyers who asked a million questions and never made an offer. Sep 8, 2023 · In today’s digital age, everything from grocery shopping to finding your soulmate can be done online. Jul 14, 2023 · i had my 94 yo mom’s Lexus that had 15k mi on it and 2-3 years old and needed to sell. Dealerships offer this now? Can I purchase a vehicle completely online thru a dealer just like I would through Carmax, Vroom, or Carvana? Or would I still have to make a trip to the dealership? Also, on these vehicles that say deliverable, on Cargurus it always lists how much extra the delivery would cost. CarGurus = 38900 Vroom = 37850 Carvana is lowballing 34000. Once you find your dream car, head to the dealer with confidence and tell them you’re pre-qualified on CarGurus. The best choice for you will ultimately depend on your specific needs, preferences, and priorities. None of them have good financing terms, so if you have good credit and your credit union offers auto loans, you should utilize them regardless of which dealer you choose. ” Derek D. Carvana gave me an egregiously overpriced offer for my car a few years back (like $19k vs $14k from CarMax), so I’d at least compare with them. No dealership had ever offered me anywhere near kbb value. I got quotes from Carvana and Carmax recently, Carmax offered $7k and Carvana offered $9500. Carvana was lower for me. Buying a car is no exception. After looking at some cars in person you should pick a make and model to start looking for. 5 days ago · CarGurus vs Autotrader: TopConsumerReviews. Cargurus wouldn't make an offer. Go thru the quote process anyway, but I wouldn’t be surprised if they decline to quote it - they won’t be able to sell it. Jun 4, 2024 · First, selling your car is free, but it may cost you $4. PM me for his cell. 5K. e. I know a lot of people are saying Carmax and such, but there really isn’t going to be a large market for an 18 year old vehicle. Nov 19, 2021 · In this Carvana vs. If both places have the exact same cars than it is just down to price. Prices from $500 to $3,250,000; Includes KBB ratings and CarFax; Cars from dealerships and private owners; Payment-based search tools; At-home test drive Appreciate the detailed info! I did a lot of price comparisons, the v6 one saves me about 4k with similar mileage (without m package), and found a 2017 v6 one with similar price and mileage with m package, so my gut feeling tells me that I'm willing to shed 15% more for a better engine, or in the case of the cpo, also better wheels. Search for used cars at carmax. This same car got kbb trade in from carmax, and I'd use carmax again. Sep 9, 2024 · Not worth it at all. By Maxwell B. I bought 2 cars from Carmax, and though they may seem more expensive than a regular dealer, remember that the dealer is going to try to add all kinds of additional fees to the price of the car, so then it's going to end up being just as expensive as Carmax, and with Carmax there is zero pressure when buying the car, and you have up to 30 days Same happened to me. Mortimer Updated: Sep 1, 2021. Feb 3, 2025 · CarMax. 6 days ago · CarMax. I don't know if that's your case. CarGurus is by far the easiest and most user friendly but i like the CARFAX integration that cars. Save $22,754 this April on a Chevrolet Corvette on CarGurus. Dec 15, 2021 · If you are in the market to purchase a used car, CarMax and Carvana both seem like great options to go with. Corolla/Civic 1-2 years old with 10-20k miles is usually at or more expensive than what you could negotiate down on a brand new car at a dealer). They probably won't wait much longer than that though, because of the 3 for free option. Autotrader does not say that anywhere. Carfax Vs. Jul 14, 2023 · FL dealers suck, I've had salesmen actually tell me to go to CarMax that they would make a better offer than the dealer even when you take the sales tax brake into consideration. Sell directly to CarMax; Payment at time of drop off; Free KBB price comparison; Payment via bank draft "A+" rated and accredited by the BBB; CarMax is a well-known used car retailer that offers a hassle-free car buying and selling experience, with a "no-haggle" pricing policy and convenient features like 24-hour test drives and home delivery. CarMax Offer: $2,200. TrueCar lacks a listing marketplace. 2 years later go to try and trade it in to carmax and they mention the Autocheck has an accident from the previous owner. UPDATED APRIL 2025 We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Sold Private: $8,999. Went to the top Lexus dealer in Boca Raton and they offered $6000 less than CarMax. With its advanced analytics and user-friendly platform, you can easily list your car privately or get an instant cash offer from a dealership, making it a convenient option if you're looking to sell your vehicle quickly and hassle-free. Oct 17, 2024 · Carvana vs. Looked at Carmax and the cars they had seemed overpriced for their mileage. 5. 2 days ago · CarMax. The process was much simpler that selling to CarMax, plus I didn’t have to deal with going in store and waiting another 2 hours. So I'm looking for another used car and I've searched the various places such as local craiglist, ebay motors, autotrader, and cargurus. Cargurus and facebook marketplace had the most hits. When you see something you like, you can use CarGurus to contact the dealer directly. com or carvana. Still in disbelief of how quick and painless it was after hearing so many horror stories of private selling This insurance subreddit is for consumers wanting their questions answered about insurance (quicker than a bigger sub where you have to wait to trend to be noticed), and P&C and L&H agents/brokers wanting to answer consumers' questions while sharing useful content in addition to asking and answering agents questions about the business. def Carvana and CarMax is more expensive but you are paying premium for not being hassled by the dealer bought 3 cars from Carmax ( one of them was brand new Jeep Grandcherokee when they were auth dealer ) and my last car was from Carvana right when pandemic started it was such a breeze to buy the car and deal with the folks or lack there of was very nice. I listed it on craigslist, nextdoor, cargurus. You can search for cars by make and model, body style (sedan, SUV, hatchbacks, minivans, coupes etc. Carvana employee here. I would really like to learn about other competitive options out there. Autonation has access to new car trades which are usually nicer. I used to work at a store 10 minutes from a Carmax. I'd tell them to go sell their car to Carmax, and give me a call. Due to my credit being in the low 600’s is there a chance CarMax will ask for a higher down payment although i pre qualified for $3,500 down? Posted by u/natesofia - 1 vote and 11 comments Jul 14, 2023 · i had my 94 yo mom’s Lexus that had 15k mi on it and 2-3 years old and needed to sell. Do your homework first. But sure, it’s “convenient. Sometime there is a delay in the reporting. Almost immediately, one dealer contacted me offering 24K, but they were 2 hours away, and on a short timeline. I have not seen that one or the other is consistently higher I think it just depends. Oct 9, 2024 · Cars. Listed 3 Days on CarGurus. 3k). They are the most straight forward seller of warrantied automobiles that I can think of. i sold my car to Shift last week and my offer was $2300 higher ($31k vs. Milwaukee, WI “CarMax helped me find financing within my price range for a beautiful car. Use CarGurus to find the best used car deals. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns. So I either have to make a 1. Tell us some details, get your pre-qualification, then shop online with real rates. Moreover, CarMax offers cash or trade-in value for your next car, while CarGurus only provides cash. I had my car on Auto Trader, CarGurus and FB marketplace for $23. CarGurus: Key Differences. Prices from $10,998 to $74,998; Sells their own cars; Long-distance delivery; Free in-home delivery "A+” rating from the BBB; Carmax is a well-established used car retailer with a unique "no-haggle" pricing model that makes car shopping a stress-free experience. CarMax has around 50,000 used cars to choose from at any given time. This way I actually met with who'd be taking my car and felt good about it. The last trade in offer I got was a flat $1000, which I laught at since it wasn't a beater car. so that can play a factor in the price adjustment. kbb or edmunds estimated 26. CarMax will also buy your car if it meets the company’s specifications. Carmax selling cars for cheaper than dealerships based on cargurus I’ve been looking at listings for Arteon’s and Mach E’s in the last few months and the best deals I’ve seen are from Carmax. BTW CarGurus website tracks the days on market to find deals. ” Jamie F. 9 billion in revenue and sold over 343,000 cars. That said, I have seen their offer prices come down since. CarMax has local lots that evaluate your car. Went to CarMax and they gave me a killer offer. It looks like the instant offer is about 10% - 15% lower than the lower bound of the range KBB provides for private sales/trade-ins and ~25% - ~42% lower than retail (based on cargurus): Could you recommend a better online platform for used cars for sale by owner? Facebook is free, local, available everywhere, etc. You wouldn't pay an extra $2k for the one at carmax just because Reddit stranger said they are better. Faster than I expected, no shenanigans. Mar 31, 2025 · Carvana. Join and Discuss evolving technology, new entrants, charging infrastructure, government policy, and the ins and outs of EV ownership right here. With that said, the company has been getting crushed for the last year, probably in large part due to making stupid offers like that. The grand cherokee is the only vehicle that has everything I want without going into a European luxury brand. CarMax also gives you a full week to drive the car to make sure you like it. This gives you many of the same protections you’d get when buying a new car May 5, 2020 · When you search for new or used vehicles, CarGurus ranks the best deals from the most trusted dealers first, so you can be confident you’re not paying too much. $33. CarGurus gave me the largest offer for my old car so far, over CarMax, but not sure how legitimate this is. they dropped the car and had it's good to have as a baseline, but i'd also consider Shift if it's available around where you live. com. I’m currently in the market to purchase a new vehicle due to my current vehicle giving me many expensive problems. When I was searching for cars a month back, 95% of what CarMax had was also on CarGurus, except with a higher price usually around $1-2k more. Figure out what is important to you and what options you can live without. Carmax has the reputation as paying a lot so they get a lot of people off the street selling there cars which can be hit or miss. Mazda3. So this is my experience. CarGurus can help make your search for a used vehicle easier. Listed less than a week on CarGurus. You're also buying convenience. Then they evaluate it and adjust the amount. If you don’t live in such a state, just sell to carmax and don’t bother with the dealer. Just use CarGurus. Oct 16, 2024 · Oh right and they, along with Carmax, tend to overprice their cars versus actual market/retail value. All of these have upsides and downsides. In my experience, listings are generally the same, especially dealer listings, but private party sellers will use different platforms. com, and facebook marketplace for 26K. 4 days ago · CarGurus is a reputable online car marketplace that's been helping people buy and sell cars since 2006. CarMax comparison guide, we will discuss how these platforms compare with each other. Run the online appraisal for both. uqaw wmmk tsgp gfsfj rpuh sxq ouurwzwv kruqxi gbkv pybvi pvxxhvj pbslse chcs uczla kywdi