Coal stove vs pellet stove A coal stove may also be equipped with an automatic stoker that enables it to burn even longer at lower temperatures. The biggest issue with our coal stove, other than the dirt and amount of ash that's generated, is the fact that on windy days we get an awful sulfur smell in the house. pellet stove can be shut of on mild days and relit when needed. Nov 2, 2014 · We're starting to get tired of the dirt and smell of our coal stove, and are thinking about replacing our coal unit with a wood pellet stove. The stove has a top 6 inch exhaust pipe and would need the same on a pellet stove. Jan 28, 2012 · The pellet stove is in the living room and coal stove is at the opposite end of the house in the kitchen. Coal is cheap. In this article, we’ll compare coal vs pellets based on different factors to help you make an informed decision. May. Pellets are cheaper and easier to store. The coal stove vs. A typical hand loaded coal stove (and wood stove) dont require electricity. Some coal stoves can generate heat for 18 to 24 hours per fuel load, which is a longer burn time than wood. Mar 7, 2022 · Wood pellet stoves also use a lot of electricity—and, in turn, produce a lot of electricity-generating CO2 emissions. If you want to heat a room, use a pellet stove. Anthracite coal produces no smoke or particulate emissions and is exempt from EPA regulation, whereas pellet and wood stoves are regulated by the EPA due to their emissions. You can expect about 24 to 25 million BTU's per ton on average from anthracite coal. They produce fewer greenhouse gases and particulate emissions compared to traditional wood-burning stoves. Keystoker Stoves arerated at 85,000 BTU/hour, but most pellet stoves are rated below 35,000 BTU/hour. I owned 2 pellet stoves previously and now I wouldn't take one if it was free. Pellet must be storeed away from moisture or else the pellets fall apart. But burned some oil too over a winter because the coal stove had no blower. They work well, are clean and easy to use, but expensive vs cutting your own. the pellet would struggle , then again you must realize its a small unit. My pellet stove heated my house ok but it is nothing like the heat a coal stove puts out. Analyzing the Price and Calorific Value Nov 19, 2024 · Pellet Stoves Vs Propane – Head to Head. Feb 16, 2014 · we always had 2 harmon coal stoves 1 insert and a free standing , still have the insert sold the other when a nice lady sold us an pdvc-25 . my friend has a pellet stove and when it gets cold out he burns 3-4 bags day to heat me I bag a day and am toasty warm this is my take on it. Which type of coal produces less ash? Nut coal produces less ash compared to stove coal. Can be burned wet. Jan 18, 2018 · There is a good wood stove in the basement but we haven't had a chance to cut wood. He even has an old chimney. 2001Sierra Member Posts: 2208 Joined: Wed. Airflow and Grate Design: Coal stoves have grates and airflow systems optimized for coal combustion. Wood needs far more labor, time, and effort to cut, stack, and season than coal. also fuel is a Jan 26, 2022 · Anthracite coal stoves or boilers also produce much more heat output as compared to pellet boilers. from what I understand about coal vs wood pellets is wood pellets is a supplemnt heat where as coal is a primary heat source I just started burning coal this year and am glad I did it vs pellet. wood pellets, the best choice often comes down to individual needs and economic factors. I dislike them that much. A wood stove does not require any power. Aug 19, 2010 · As a previous pellet stove burner and a new hand fired coal stove burner I will say this. pellet stove debate doesn’t have a one-size-fits-all answer when it comes to cost-effectiveness. However, if Anthracite is available in your area, the benefits lean heavily in its favor. Coal Stoves. but for sure heat, coal . 20, 2009 1:09 pm Hot Air Coal Stoker Stove: Keystoker 90 Chimney vent Coal Size/Type: Rice Other Heating: Buderus Oil Boiler 3115-34 Sep 21, 2013 · My cousin in law just bought an $800 pellet stove. Pellet stoves come in two styles: Free standing – stands in the open; Insert – fits into a wall; Pellet stoves are installed in one location and that’s where they stay. Anthracite is safer because it creates no residual creosote build-up. love the pellets ez to feed etc. Coal stoves are also very inexpensive. Substantially more ash with coal and disposal isn't as environmentally friendly as ash from the pellet stove. I gave him my advice regarding pellets vs coal several times over, and yet he bought one anyway. 04, 2010 4:54 pm Hand Fed Coal Stove: Blower Model Coal Chubby 1982-Serial#0097 Hot Air Coal Stoker Stove: Harman 1998 Magnum Stoker Pellet stove require electricity. Any suggestions for the pellet stove? The Harman stove can put out a lot of heat which is hard to regulate the heat. Coal is Much More Readily Available and Easier to Store Mar 15, 2006 · I've noticed in comparing the amount of ash that I get per unit volume of burned coal, vs. Hence, coal stoves can produce much more heat per hour and/or burn twice as long. Been buying the "gren heat" wood blocks. While coal burners run on coal, pellet stoves require wood pellets to operate. Which type of coal is more expensive? Stove coal is typically more expensive than nut coal. coal can be turned down on mild days and you open your windows and wait all day for it to go out,then clean all the ash out then go through the Feb 13, 2012 · The coal stove can also take short pieces of wood if we want to take the chill off the kitchen at times. Pellet stoves are considered more environmentally friendly due to their use of renewable fuel. Jan 20, 2008 · I was thinking of getting a pellet stove to replace the coal stove. Coal and pellet stoves are two distinct types of stoves that use various fuels to operate. Pellet stoves require power to turn the auger that feeds the pellets. 6 Latrobe Baltimore Heater Coal Size/Type: 'nut & stove Other Heating: Fujitsu mini split, FHA oil furnace Oct 26, 2016 · I used to burn 40-50lb of coal per day, maybe 60 on some cold days. In a power outage no pellet burning. One of the best things about using wood pellets in your fireplace is that it helps save energy. Additionally, modern pellet stoves are almost maintenance-free and produce minimal ash, which can be repurposed as valuable garden fertilizer. The coal stove can throw off significantly more heat than the pellet stove and when loaded and properly attended to can burn easily through a night and into the morning. It is true of many cast iron pellet stoves or the new futuristic cabinet style pellet stoves, that they are touchable in many cases. If you lose power, the feed auger and draft blower stop and your fire dies. Coal stoves are clean burning Mar 28, 2024 · In the contest of anthracite coal vs. Been looking at pellet stoves, but someone recommended a coal stove that works the same way, but puts out a LOT more BTUs. Using wood pellets in a coal stove may result in inefficient burning, reducing heat output and potentially causing damage to the furnace. Our coal stove is a 6" direct vent Lignite coal which is lowest grade of coal may only have 14 million BTU's per ton, the highest quality anthracite can exceed 28 million. The pellet stove does not heat like coal but i also don't have the mess or a problem disposing of all the ash the coal stove produced. However, cooking can also be done on a coal stove. The BTU content of wood is particularity problematic in these estimates. % ash from wood pellet stoves, that coal seems to come out on the short end of the stick. May 5, 2024 · Coal stoves are generally less expensive to purchase than pellet stoves. Coal stoves look very similar to wood stoves; however, they have longer burn times and can put out more heat. Pro: Clean Burning. Coal. Keystoker Anthracite Stoves are capable of putting out twice as much heat as most pellet stoves. when its 0 out house stays a nice 70 or so . With the pellet stove oil is still an option but I don't have to use it. Dec 3, 2024 · Stove coal is better for overnight burning due to its slower burn rate and longer-lasting heat output. Which type of coal is better for smaller stoves? Jan 15, 2025 · Pellet stoves offer a more environmentally friendly alternative as they use renewable biomass fuel. Homeowners must consider local fuel prices, maintenance expenses, and their willingness to operate manually. Go to someones house that has a pellet stove, and then go to a house with a coal stove and see which is more comfortable. You can lead a horse to water, but you can't force it to drink. Coal stoves start from $1,300, with an additional $500 for installation at a minimum. I'd throw out a rough estimate that I get 15 pounds of ash per 100 lbs burned coal, vs 1 lb ash per 100 lbs burned wood pellets. Which Stove Is Right for You? The best choice between a propane stove and a pellet stove depends on your individual needs and preferences Sep 21, 2013 · Hambden Bob Member Posts: 8842 Joined: Mon. 2. Both have advantages and disadvantages and deciding which one to use depends on your preferences and location. . Therefore, if comfort is a priority, pellet fuel is the clear winner. Coal and Pellets Price and Calorific Value: Pellets vs. 4. Coal contains around 14,000BTU/lb while pellets only contain around 8,500 BTU/lb. It doesnt attract moisture, rot or bugs. coal can be turned down on mild days and you open your windows and wait all day for it to go out,then clean all the ash out then go through the Mar 6, 2014 · Hand Fed Coal Stove: Vigilant 2310, gold marc box stove with blower Hot Air Coal Stoker Stove: LeisureLine Hyfire ll Baseburners & Antiques: Home Sparkle 12 Glenwood no. Nov 7, 2023 · Coal and wood pellet stoves are designed with different combustion characteristics in mind. However, it is important to remember that wood pellet stoves still use a lot of electricity. Keystoker manufactures units that are capable of up to 500,000 BTU. Jan. Sep 26, 2017 · Coal stoves have a longer burn time than other types of fuel stoves. Pellet stoves are more efficient and require less maintenance than coal stoves. 3. When it comes to home heating, coal and pellets are two popular choices. This is especially true when you factor in coal stoves, which are built heavier and require less maintenance than pellet stoves. A wood stove can heat a whole house if placed correctly and sized properly. You can only turn the coal stove up so far before you use lose the fire. zcad cnxvrka epf gnlsioy nqddk hcmnf jrot gcqhgr lahp xuc zucu alpkn lnxw ftkmqu yegaex